Oceania Cruises review: Unlawful failure to return cruise fee of $12,600 approximately for nautical cruise on Nov 18, 2023, Inv # 3503752. 1

Attached please find some forwards between my agent, myself and Oceania Cruises over the past few weeks.

I have been requesting a full refund for the past three weeks from Oceania because of the War Zone that now exists and continues to exist in the Middle East. I had planned a trip on the Nautica throughout the Middle East, including Israel. Being Jewish immediately made me believe that we should not take the trip in the Middle East because all the Arab Muslim countries (including Turkey) support Hamas who want to destroy Israel and kill all Jews.

Ironically, Oceania informed me throughout this scenario that I can cancel, and if so, the penalty is 100 percent, loss of entire cruise fee of $12,600 approximately. No option was ever available to me, but to go on a cruise it created, but not the one I purchased.

Destination Israel was taken off the itinerary about three weeks ago, and now, by way of Carlos E. Ortega, VP of Global Guest Services email (copy attached), the balance of the cruise, but for the departure port, Dubai was removed from the cruise. I was informed by Oceania from the outset that it was considering its options and that an email providing a refund or credit would be provided to all guests. I never saw any email, but I did see Mr. Ortega's email a few days ago.

Oceania participated in bait and switch, leading me on to believe that I would receive an email providing me options, but it never came.

The bottom line is that Oceania has breached its contract with me since I did not purchase a cruise throughout Europe; and to compound the situation, Oceania has committed fraud by its bait and switch unlawful tactics compelling me to go through a war zone and end up in an Arab Muslim Country being a Jew.

To date, Oceania continues refusing to return in full my cruise fees of $12,600. I do not anticipate that Oceania will refund to me my cruise fees of $12,500, of which there is no justification for this unlawful position.

I request that Oceania forward this email to its legal counsel to provide a response to me supporting the basis for its unlawful position. Absent immediately receiving a full refund, I intend to prosecute an action against Oceania for Breach of Contract and Fraud, etc. I also intend to inform other guests on the Nautica of the illegal conduct undertaken by Oceania in this matter.

Very truly yours,

Frank Mulberg, Attorney

Mail Address: PO Box 909 Mill Valley CA 94942

415.388.0605(tel) 415.388.6929(fax)

Cell: [protected]

Contact me at [protected]

----- Forwarded Message -----

From: Zabdy Constant

To: Frankmulberg

Sent: Wednesday, October 25, 2023 at 10:51:39 AM PDT

Subject: Re: NAUTICA 11-18-2023: Booking: 3503752 Guest: MULBERG - Important Itinerary Update

Good afternoon,

I will resend the cruise confirmation email over to you. I have forwarded everything to our management team that will be taking over and assisting you.

Zabdy Constant

Master Cruise Counselor

Travel Counselor

Vacations To Go

[protected]@vacationstogo.com

My office hours: Sun: 1pm-10pm, Mon-Thu: 10am-7pm (US Central Time)

US and Canada: [protected] ext. 7893

For toll-free numbers from other countries, click here.

How am I doing? To rate my service or request contact by a manager, please click here.

Happy with my service? Please share my contact information with your family and friends.

From: Frankmulberg

Sent: Wednesday, October 25, 2023 10:28 AM

To: Zabdy Constant

Subject: Re: NAUTICA 11-18-2023: Booking: 3503752 Guest: MULBERG - Important Itinerary Update

Good morning, Zadby,

Do you have a copy of our purchase contract with Oceana?

We bought one cruise, they lied and stalled for 3 to 4 weeks, waiting

For an email that was going to give us options: bait and switch.

This is a breach of contract and a misrepresentation, bad faith.

I bought a Middle East trip and now i have something that I did not purchase.

Can you put me in touch with a high level officer at Oceana. Also

Can you put me in touch with a high level officer in vacations to go.

I need to get in touch with other passengers on the cruise immediately.

Can you obtain that for me, an email address. I want to know who is on

The boat that is going to dubai.

I do not want to go to Dubai as I am Jewish and the Arabs are United and

Support Hamas who want to kill Jews.

Aside from a breach of contract by Oceana, the dept of state has informed citizens

To get out of the Middle East because it is in a war zone. Is Oceana serious about

What they want us to do.

I want a complete refund from Oceana.

Zadby, please forward this email to a high level officer at Oceana,

As well as a high level officer at your own company.

Can I be put in contact with your legal department to pursue a remedy?

Thank you.

Frank Mulberg

Attorney at Law

Sent from my iPhone

On Oct 25, 2023, at 6:16 AM, Zabdy Constant wrote:



The cruise line has changed the itinerary for the safety of the guests, so they are not canceling the cruise or offering options.

The cruise line will not give anyone a list of passenger's names as that would violate their privacy.

Zabdy Constant

Master Cruise Counselor

Travel Counselor

Vacations To Go

[protected]@vacationstogo.com

My office hours: Sun: 1pm-10pm, Mon-Thu: 10am-7pm (US Central Time)

US and Canada: [protected] ext. 7893

For toll-free numbers from other countries, click here.

How am I doing? To rate my service or request contact by a manager, please click here.

Happy with my service? Please share my contact information with your family and friends.

From: Frankmulberg

Sent: Tuesday, October 24, 2023 6:45:30 PM

To: Zabdy Constant

Subject: Re: NAUTICA 11-18-2023: Booking: 3503752 Guest: MULBERG - Important Itinerary Update

Zabdy,

Did you ever receive an email offering from Oceana that was supposed to be sent offering options?

Did you ask for a list of customers as I asked you to do?

Frank Mulberg

Sent from my iPhone

On Oct 24, 2023, at 4:29 PM, Zabdy Constant wrote:



Good afternoon,

I have followed up with the CruiseLine again. The agent stated effective today, Oceania is no longer offering the FCC option due to the fact that they have changed the itinerary to ensure guests safety during this cruise.

I requested for a supervisor for further assistance and they made the same statement. If you were to cancel the cruise the cancellation penalties remain in place.

Zabdy Constant

Master Cruise Counselor

Travel Counselor

Vacations To Go

[protected]@vacationstogo.com

My office hours: Sun: 1pm-10pm, Mon-Thu: 10am-7pm (US Central Time)

US and Canada: [protected] ext. 7893

For toll-free numbers from other countries, click here.

How am I doing? To rate my service or request contact by a manager, please click here.

Happy with my service? Please share my contact information with your family and friends.

From: Frankmulberg

Sent: Tuesday, October 24, 2023 5:53 PM

To: Zabdy Constant

Subject: Fwd: NAUTICA 11-18-2023: Booking: 3503752 Guest: MULBERG - Important Itinerary Update

Good afternoon, zabdy,

Attached is Oceana email, essentially, cancelling cruise since it nothing like the cruise I signed up for. Of course, they should have just cancelled the cruise given the explosive situation in the Middle East.

Please contact Oceana and request a refund, all money back., not because we are cancelling cruise, because Oceana has cancelled cruise by their own actions. We have many plans to attend to concerning money back for airline tickets, hotels, outside excursions, etc. Will Oceana reimburse us for any losses we sustain.

I also would like a list from Oceana of all customers not going on cruise because of new itineraries and explosive situation in Middle East.

Call me if you have any questions.

Best,

Frank Mulberg

Sent from my iPhone

Begin forwarded message:

From: Oceania Cruises

Date: October 24, 2023 at 12:39:22 PM PDT

To: [protected]@vacationstogo.com

Cc: [protected]@yahoo.com, [protected]@comcast.net

Subject: NAUTICA 11-18-2023: Booking: 3503752 Guest: MULBERG - Important Itinerary Update



IMPORTANT NOTIFICATION

CONCERNING YOUR CRUISE RESERVATION

Guest Names:

Cruise: NAUTICA 18NOV2023

MRS SHELLEY MULBERG

Group #:

MR FRANK MULBERG

Invoice #: 3503752

Travel Agency: VACATIONS TO GO

Travel Advisor: ZABDY CONSTANT

Dear Valued Guests and Travel Advisors,

Further to the previously communicated itinerary changes to your November 18, 2023, voyage, we’ve made some additional revisions as the safety, security and peace of mind of our guests and crew remain our top priorities.

The amended itinerary is below with the revisions in bold. The updated itinerary now features a selection of historically significant and culturally rich destinations, such as Florence, Rome, Athens and Crete. The complete, revised, day-by-day itinerary with arrival and departure times may be found at OceaniaCruises.com.

DATE

NEW ITINERARY

November 18, 2023

Barcelona, Spain

November 19, 2023

Toulon, France

November 20, 2023

Florence/Pisa/Tuscany (Livorno), Italy

November 21, 2023

Rome (Civitavecchia), Italy

November 22, 2023

Naples, Italy

November 23, 2023

Messina (Sicily), Italy

November 24, 2023

Valletta, Malta

November 25, 2023

At Sea

November 26, 2023

Athens (Piraeus), Greece

November 27, 2023

Heraklion (Crete), Greece

November 28, 2023

At Sea

November 29, 2023

Suez Canal Transit

November 30, 2023

At Sea

December 1, 2023

At Sea

December 2, 2023

At Sea

December 3, 2023

At Sea

December 4, 2023

At Sea

December 5, 2023

At Sea

December 6, 2023

At Sea

December 7, 2023

Dubai, UAE

December 8, 2023

Dubai, UAE

We look forward to welcoming you on board.

Very best regards,

Carlos E. Ortega | Vice President, Global Guest Services

Should you have any questions, please contact your Travel Advisor or Oceania Cruises at:

United States and Canada 855-OCEANIA [protected])

United Kingdom [protected]

Germany, Austria and Switzerland +[protected]

Spain +[protected]

France +[protected]

Sweden +46 (8) [protected]

Israel +[protected]

Rest of Europe, Middle East, & Africa +[protected]

Australia [protected]

New Zealand [protected]

Singapore +[protected] / Malaysia +60 3-[protected] / India +91 22-[protected]

Taiwan +886 2-[protected] / Hong Kong and the rest of Asia +[protected]

China [protected]

Latin America +[protected] / Brazil [protected]

Please note this email does not accept replies.

This email was sent by Oceania Cruises

7665 Corporate Center Drive, Miami, FL, 33126, USA