BuckEyePuppies.com
Reviews and Complaints

We bought a shipoo two weeks ago. We love him but he's had diarrhea since day one
The person met us, we were not permitted to go see his parents
We met in new Concord, Ohio
Paid 450$ for him, I talk with lady that brought him to us but very good at covering
I'm angry at all this
Places like puppy mills need to shut down
He hides a lot like he's scared to death
We've got him to where he plays a little
I don't want to part with him, but they need to pay vet if he doesn't get better

I bought the sweetest schnoodle from Buckeye Puppies. The following was my experience:

The puppy was given some sort of drug just before our meeting. They had to physically put him in my lap when we met and he was completely unresponsive, to food, to physical contact, even to sound - the entire 3+ hour drive home.

He would only go the restroom on concrete and didn’t know what to do in real grass. (Though the woman said he’d just been outside with her while she was hanging laundry!?!

He didn’t know how to drink from a bowl and had to be taught. (Like he’d only drunk from a water bottle.) He always sat with his back against the wall, even when he slept.

Lastly, He was supposedly up to date on all of his puppy inoculations when I got him, and had even been to the vet with me (with the list of shots, so they didn’t inoculate him further, as he was “up to date) - he died of Parvo at the age of 6 months.

This place is a puppy mill and those puppies are being treated horribly. They should be shut down. Please do not support this business!

This Page is littered with Puppy Mills who create click bait ads, by advertising a pup saying it registered/registrable but to get the registration esp. AKC you have to pay double the price. So basically, you are paying for a registration not a puppy. Then come to find out these registrations are fraudulent. When you send in to get a pedigree from AKC you will find the pedigree is littered with unregistered dogs. How did this dog get registered in the first place. AKC has lost its integrity and dignity to cater to these USDA puppy mills for making that Almighty dollar. OH, IN, PA Have become so filled with these puppy mills and most sorry to say are Mennonite large USDA breeding facilities, Where the breeding dogs (stock) are treated like cattle left in cages all their life to pump out puppies every 6 months. Then to be discarded or put down at around age 5 when her reproductive system starts to decline. NO socialization. The puppies they sell may be alright, but the Parents suffer.

Have purchased several AKC pups I and friends only to find out that these dogs have a worthless pedigree. The pedigree is litter with unregistered dogs. While AKC used to be a reliable and reputable registry like everything else has sunk into fraudulent tactics for the almighty dollar. They don't test for purebred of the dog via DNA, they use pedigree research which is crock of crap to say your dog is pure breed. I would trust ACA registry more than AKC for your purebred, However ACA will register AKC dogs on their registry. Ask to see pedigrees if you really want a pure-bred dog especially if it supposed to be AKC. You can also find other articles talking about the shading dealings of AKC. And in case you don't know AKC has moved it main offices from NC to NYC the city of scams.

Hello, I purchased a puppy from Joe Mast and Betty Stutzman from Ohio last month. I was promised a healthy vaccinated puppy and what I got was the total opposite. She died 3 weeks and almost $8,000 later from distemper. I was told by the vet she was unfit for sale and I feel these people need to be taken off your website and held responsible for this awful thing they did to my puppy. If it weren’t for them Milly would still be here with us today. I have ever vet bill and ever text and email saved so if you need more information please let me know

Betty is the middle man for puppy mills to sell their dogs to people all over the country. Buckeye Puppies recently brokered a Bernadoodle to a buyer in NJ. The Bernadoodle was diagnosed with pneumonia a week later and is now dying of distemper yet Betty has done nothing to hold the breeder ( Joe and Arlene Mast of Baltic OH) accountable for selling sick dogs. She says on her website "fI we receive a report or complaint about a seller, we investigate, take down their advertisements, and ban the seller if necessary." But she has not taken down his ads and continues to promote his puppy mill and sick dogs.

This entire dog selling business is horrible and the Amish treat these animals like livestock, not pets. I highly suggest you go to a local breeder you can visit many times to see the conditions or better yet ADOPT from your local shelter.

I purchased a shitzu poodle from Rachel Raber back in June 2021. I called her a month after and asked if she was sure the breeding was in fact a shitzu poodle mix. She swore that it was. I went forward to purchase a very expensive DNA test from DNA my dog. and Come to find out my dog is mostly schnauzer, and some poodle and some bichon. I feel as if I have been lied to and deceived. I would like to know what you will do about this, and I would like to ask for compensation for being lied to. My email is [protected]@ncalife.org and my phone number is [protected], I would be happy to send you the report,

This website seems legit but is not. They lied about the breed of dog, parents of dog, used a broker when the website says they don't, didn't give vaccinations as stated, didn't get a vet check as stated, didn't use dewormed as stated. Basically everything on this website was a lie. I researched for quite some time to get a dog we wanted, but ended up leaving with something completely different. This website lies. DO NOT TRUST this website!

This company is as shady as they get. Just spotted company car driving from puppy mill to puppy mill here in indiana. Extremely reckless drivers. And do t be fooled when website claims they only advertise. They go to puppy mills and buy a large number of sick dogs or dogs with health problems that may not be seen right away such as heart murmur or joint problems and so on. They buy large numbers of dogs at cheap prices then sell at full retail.

I bought a thought was a standard poodle from buckeye puppies. He is not full standard poodle and I paid a lot of money for him. I am so pissed because that is what I wanted. I ask them was it full blood standard poodle and he is not . He is a labordoodle or goldendoodle or something mixed. He is a really cute puppy, but he is hot what I paid for. and these people are cheating people out f their money and I want a refund or at the very least half my money back

Buckeyepuppies.com
And
Lancaster puppies.com
Is owned by the same Amish people/business

Two different breeders clearly advertise on their sites.
1. Amish puppy mills
And
2. Normal dog breeders (not Amish)

For all puppy adoptees not aware.
They continuously harass the dog breeders that advertise on there that are not Amish.

They would prefer only the Amish advertise on their Amish puppy websites owned by theses Amish people. When other good dog breeders try to advertise on their so-called public classified site. They harass us !

They (lancasterpuppies & buckeye puppies) harbor, protect, disquise and support these Amish puppy mills. they go out to their farms they take their pups pictures, they post those pictures on their website and charge $35 a puppy.

they don't like us regular breeders because we take our own pictures, do our own ads and they only get $15 per puppy from us. Which is approximately 5 times as much as any other classified site by the way.

Decent breeders are harassed stalked and kicked off of their websites on a regular basis because the Amish puppy mills complain that there are too many of regular small breeders on their site and they get less business now. People now go on to these websites and have choices. They can go to small family run homes where puppies are raised inside their homes and the parents are inside their homes and the puppies are under foot being raised.
Or ~ they can go to the Amish puppy mills where the parents and the puppies are in their dark barns and never step foot into the actual family's home.

These two classified puppy websites don't like us regular breeders advertising on their site. They prefer the Amish puppy mills.

I purchased a Boston Terrier puppy from a breeder advertising on this site. The pup was sick and I ended up taking him to the Animal hospital within 24 hours of purchase. He has pneumonia. Has been on antibiotics ever since. The breeder will not respond. I know nothing can be done at this point. All I would like now is to have the breeder banned from selling on their site going forward. I emailed them, but was just told to contact the breeder. No help there.

I realize that BuckeyePuppies.com is just a listing site, but BUYER BEWARE! We adopted a beagle last Friday from a home at the address provided above. The "breeder" said the puppy had "had all his puppy shots" and had been "dewormed." We got him home on Friday, 7/26/19 at 4:00 and had him at the vet the next morning at 11:30 due to extreme itching. We found out he has mange! That will be at least a month's treatment and the poor dog is suffering. At the same time we provided a stool specimen. We just got the results back today (Tuesday, 7/30/19) and the puppy has roundworm and giardia! We may as well have adopted a stray animal!
I reached out to the "breeder" that I had been texting with, who is the wife of the man we saw when we bought the puppy. Her response when I informed her of what we had discovered - which is all I did - inform her - I didn't make any demand of any kind - - was to basically call me a liar. She said they hadn't had any other complaints about any puppy they've ever sold and that she "didn't really know what to tell me." I followed up with her asking if we could just have the specific vaccination information that we had asked for repeatedly. She responded that she didn't know the specifics, just "your basic puppy shots."
I then texted saying that her response of, "I don't really know what to tell you, " was completely inappropriate and that an expression of concern for the puppy and an offer to make things right were in order. Her response, "Yeah, well, when we had the puppy, there was nothing wrong with it." Unbelievable. Just unbelievable. Yeah, the puppy obviously got mange, round worm and giardia within the 30 hours that we had him in our home prior to taking him to the vet and not from the barn they kept him.
So, we paid $200 (I know, that should have been my first red flag) for a totally UNHEALTHY puppy and the "breeder" never expressed the least concern about the poor thing's health. Please don't EVER buy a puppy from the Miller's who live on this street and I would suggest taking ANY puppy you buy from Amish country to the vet for a check PRIOR to paying for it. This is just despicable, dishonest and unethical behavior. I so regret my decision and would NEVER buy a dog this way again! It's worth it to pay more for a dog from a REPUTABLE breeder, which may not describe many of the dogs on Buckeyepuppies.com.

I adopted a beabull, or so i thought it was a beabull, 1 year ago. Come to find out, as the dog got older that he was in fact a boxer beagle instead of a bulldog beagle. Not only that but the dog was traumatized from the day i brought him home. He is scared of everything, extremely aggressive, possessive over his toys etc. I have put everything in to helping this dog and make him feel loved and treated well. This company treats their animals like toys and send them off to just about anywhere just so they can make a dollar. It sickens me that the little puppy i brought home went through so much in the first 6 weeks of his life to the point that he can't get past it a year later with constant love and affection. Not to mention when i brought him home, he had scratches all over his head from fighting with another dog and he also was very hesitant and almost grouchy when someone would touch him. That is NOT how a puppy should behave! I feel so sympathetic for anyone who has gone through this and the amount of time and energy that goes into fixing it is out of this world. PLEASE do not adopt from this place, it is the absolute worst thing you could do. Wayne and Mary are the people i adopted from as well, avoid every part of them.

Stay away from the company Buckeye Puppies, because the owner is liar. Every two weeks she updated information on the website. She had puppies of different breeds and it was suspicious. When I asked about the parents of the puppy, she tried to avoid the question and didn’t tell precisely. I wanted to buy the puppy from her, but her behaviour was too uptight. I simply decided to share with my suspicions.