Menu
For Business Write a review File a complaint
Five Star Bank Customer Service Phone, Email, Contacts

Five Star Bank
Reviews and Complaints

www.five-starbank.com

Learn how the rating is calculated

4.3 6 Complaints
Claim Your Business
Take control of your profile: address complaints and engage with reviews
Write a review File a complaint

Five Star Bank Complaints 6

ComplaintsBoard
R
1:22 am EDT
Verified customer The reviewer confirmed their account using Google. Learn more
Featured review
This review was chosen algorithmically as the most valued customer feedback.

I fell behind on my car payment due to being in an accident back in December. I’ve been trying to catch up and have recently had the $ to start paying Five Star Bank back for my car. They repossessed it 3 days ago and I still cannot get in contact with Five Star no matter how many times I call. I was told that Josie DaMore would handle my case and let me...

Read full review of Five Star Bank and 1 comment
ComplaintsBoard
M
Verified customer This complaint was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
Five Star Bank has left an official reply on this complaint.

Five Star Bank I missed two payments on my car and FIVE STAR BANK took my car

I missed two payments on my car and FIVE STAR BANK took my car . I have called multiple times through out the week and have left voicemails with Josie to pay yet NOONE called me back , or took my call for payment .

Read full review of Five Star Bank
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.

Hide full review
ComplaintsBoard
C
Verified customer This complaint was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
Five Star Bank has left an official reply on this complaint.

Five Star Bank I was behind on my car payment due to my wife losing her jobs due to covid

I was behind on my car payment due to my wife losing her jobs due to covid. We are getting back on our feet and getting caught up. I tried to make a $500 payment to Josie D on 10/29. She would not take it and said I needed $1,410 as soon as I could. I said I would have it by Monday 11/1. I had the money by noon on 10/30 and tried to make a payment in full. The customer service rep told me she could not take the full amount as Collections is not in on Saturday and that I had to talk to Josie on Monday at 8am. The car was repossessed on Monday morning at 6am. When I talked to Josie, she said I now needed over $2,400 because of what happened. If the payment was accepted on Saturday, I could have been caught up. Now I am going to have a repo, as I am now short $600 in late fees and the repo charge.

Read full review of Five Star Bank
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.

Hide full review

Is Five Star Bank Legit?

Five Star Bank earns a trustworthiness rating of 100%

Highly recommended, but caution will not hurt.

Our conclusion: Five Star Bank stands out for their exceptional legitimacy, according to ComplaintsBoard’s detailed analysis. This highlights Five Star Bank's reputation as a trustworthy leader in their field. Customers can rely on Five Star Bank's services, assured they're dealing with a highly reputable and fully legitimate company.

We found clear and detailed contact information for Five Star Bank. The company provides a physical address, 2 phone numbers, and 2 emails, as well as 5 social media accounts. This demonstrates a commitment to customer service and transparency, which is a positive sign for building trust with customers.

By resolving 83% of 6 negative reviews, Five Star Bank is demonstrating its dedication to customer satisfaction and effectively addressing customer issues. While there may still be some practical problems that need to be addressed, such as long wait times or unhelpful responses.

The age of Five Star Bank's domain suggests that they have had sufficient time to establish a reputation as a reliable source of information and services. This can provide reassurance to potential customers seeking quality products or services.

Five-starbank.com has a valid SSL certificate, which indicates that the website is secure and trustworthy. Look for the padlock icon in the browser and the "https" prefix in the URL to confirm that the website is using SSL.

Five-starbank.com has been deemed safe to visit, as it is protected by a cloud-based cybersecurity solution that uses the Domain Name System (DNS) to help protect networks from online threats.

We looked up Five Star Bank and found that the website is receiving a high amount of traffic. This could be a sign of a popular and trustworthy website, but it is still important to exercise caution and verify the legitimacy of the site before sharing any personal or financial information

Five-starbank.com regularly updates its policies to reflect changes in laws, regulations. These policies are easy to find and understand, and they are written in plain language that is accessible to all customers. This helps customers understand what they are agreeing to and what to expect from Five Star Bank.

ComplaintsBoard
C
Verified customer This complaint was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
Five Star Bank has left an official reply on this complaint.

Five Star Bank In January I fell to financial hardship due to COVID 19

In January I fell to financial hardship due to COVID 19. I reached out to 5 star bank to see about doing a deferment on my car loan. I spoke to Nicole and she told me that I didn't need to do anything and that I qualified for a 60 day deferment and my next payment would be due in March. On February 5th I received a nasty phone call from Denise in collections asking why I hadn't paid my car payment. I explained to her that I was working with Nicole and that she said I was good to go. Denise told me that wasn't the case and that my car payment was late. I asked Denise to connect me to a manager on many different occasions and she never would. I got everything squared away and made my payments. Fast forward to March and my credit score has dropped over 40 points from a missed payment from 5 star. I still can not get in touch with any manager. I've left voicemails and sent emails.

Read full review of Five Star Bank
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.

Hide full review
ComplaintsBoard
O
Verified customer This complaint was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
Five Star Bank has left an official reply on this complaint.

Five Star Bank Over the past month I have contacted the customer service line on multiple occasions

Over the past month I have contacted the customer service line on multiple occasions. I have bi-weekly payments scheduled to come out and needed to change the dates to semi monthly. The representative told me I don't have automatic payments set up with them but I 100% do and have since the day I purchased my vehicle. They have overdrafted my checking account twice now by taking out the payment on a day other than my pay day that I provided. I have attempted to resolve this with Five Star Bank directly, I have shown proof to my bank regarding the situation, and my next step will be placing a stop payment on the transactions from occurring and obtaining a loan through another bank to pay them off completely. Five Star Bank has by far the worst customer service of any bank I've dealt with in my life. I also plan to file a complaint with the attorney general if this isn't resolved this week.

Read full review of Five Star Bank
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.

Hide full review
ComplaintsBoard
V
Verified customer This complaint was posted by a verified customer. Learn more
Resolved
The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.
Replied
Five Star Bank has left an official reply on this complaint.

Five Star Bank I paid my payment for December on January 8th

I paid my payment for December on January 8th. Then I paid January's payment on the 22nd but they said it didn't get there til the 27th even though my bank shows it was sent on time. They sent to credit karma that it was 30 days late. My payments are not late until the 22nd of each Month. So at end of January it's not possible to be 30 days late. Now I made my February's payment and it said on time. My loan amount still says the same balance owed as the previous month. I have never filed a complaint before. I talked to a Patricia K on the phone and thru emails. She went through my account and said I have never made a payment 30 days late. She also verified when I did make a payment a few days late that I paid the extra late fee. So please help me fix this issue. I just paid an additional 600.00 in March. I'm seeing horrible stories about this bank. Something seriously needs to be fixed. The lady that I spoke to was very kind and told me to dispute this. I don't think it's the entire bank but there is someone definitely corrupt. Sincerely

Read full review of Five Star Bank and 1 comment
Resolved

The complaint has been investigated and resolved to the customer’s satisfaction.

Hide full review
1 comment
Add a comment
M
M
Mao Futah
US
Mar 20, 2024 3:02 am EDT
Verified customer This complaint was posted by a verified customer. Learn more

I allegedly fell behind on 2 paymeit's. And when I told Josie I would have the payment in full and 2 weeks. She refused to work with me. Is there any other person that's above her that I can talk to that's professional and won't hang up on me even though I have the full payment. In my hand

Five Star Bank Reviews 0

Looks like Five Star Bank has no reviews yet.
Write a review
Subscribe to receive notifications of all new customer feedback

If you represent Five Star Bank, take charge of your business profile by claiming it and stay informed about any new reviews or complaints submitted.

👉 Claim your business

Overview of Five Star Bank complaint handling

Five Star Bank reviews first appeared on Complaints Board on Apr 30, 2023. The latest review My car was posted on Sep 29, 2023. The latest complaint I missed two payments on my car and FIVE STAR BANK took my car was resolved on May 14, 2023. Five Star Bank has an average consumer rating of 4 stars from 6 reviews. Five Star Bank has resolved 5 complaints.
Trust badge
Collect Your Trust Badge
Be recognized for outstanding customer service
  1. Five Star Bank Contacts

  2. Five Star Bank phone numbers
    +1 (315) 536-1000
    +1 (315) 536-1000
    Click up if you have successfully reached Five Star Bank by calling +1 (315) 536-1000 phone number 0 0 users reported that they have successfully reached Five Star Bank by calling +1 (315) 536-1000 phone number Click down if you have unsuccessfully reached Five Star Bank by calling +1 (315) 536-1000 phone number 0 0 users reported that they have UNsuccessfully reached Five Star Bank by calling +1 (315) 536-1000 phone number
    +1 (716) 308-9817
    +1 (716) 308-9817
    Click up if you have successfully reached Five Star Bank by calling +1 (716) 308-9817 phone number 0 0 users reported that they have successfully reached Five Star Bank by calling +1 (716) 308-9817 phone number Click down if you have unsuccessfully reached Five Star Bank by calling +1 (716) 308-9817 phone number 0 0 users reported that they have UNsuccessfully reached Five Star Bank by calling +1 (716) 308-9817 phone number
  3. Five Star Bank emails
  4. Five Star Bank address
    55 N Main St, Warsaw, New York, 14569-1325, United States
  5. Five Star Bank social media
  6. Michael
    Checked and verified by Michael This contact information is personally checked and verified by the ComplaintsBoard representative. Learn more
    May 13, 2024
Five Star Bank Category
Five Star Bank is ranked 191 among 414 companies in the Banks category

Our Commitment

We stand for unbiased reviews

We make sure all complaints and reviews are from real people sharing genuine experiences.

We help resolving issues

We offer easy tools for businesses and reviewers to solve issues together. Learn how it works.

We advocate freedom of speech

We support and promote the right for reviewers to express their opinions and ideas freely without censorship or restrictions, as long as it's respectful and within our Terms and Conditions, of course ;)

We ensure transparent and fair ratings

Our rating system is open and honest, ensuring unbiased evaluations for all businesses on the platform. Learn more.

We care about your privacy

Personal details of reviewers are strictly confidential and hidden from everyone.

We are easy, free and open to everyone

Our website is designed to be user-friendly, accessible, and absolutely free for everyone to use.